Featured Sponsor
Look! In the Window! A Cultural Construct
Published March 17, 2003
It is fascinating to read about the history of the automobile, and to realize that for many urban populations it once represented a major means by which they realized "nature." Thus, for example, the 1925 Bronx River Parkway from New York City into Westchester County was originally conceived by Frederick Law Olmsted, who designed Central Park, as a "scenic utopia" reflecting an "authentic" American landscape (see Gandy’s Concrete and Clay, 2002). It was planted with over 30,000 trees, each selected to represent those that were, or might have been, indigenous to the area. In this, it was similar to Olmstea’s Fens and Riverway project in Boston, which replaced acres of polluted mud flats with carefully engineered and designed "natural" patterns and plantings -- or, for that matter, Central Park itself, a supremely engineered statement of what "nature" was for a city determined to ascend into the elite league of world cities.
Many interesting threads lead from these seemingly simple examples. One could, for example, examine how the Parkway, and other roads like it, helped break down the physical boundaries of the city. One could contemplate "nature" as thus constructed from many angles: conservation of species, reconstruction of (highly idealized) landscapes, statements of power and class in a rapidly developing, immigrant-rich America. Thus, for example, Robert Moses designed low bridges over his parkway to Jones Beach on Long Island to prevent buses, and thus the lower classes, from accessing it -- although there was plenty of parking for the cars of the middle class. One could contemplate how each project explicitly redefined "nature" as a designed and built environment at the time, yet came to be seen by future generations as "natural" in a foundational sense.
But another aspect caught my eye. Referring to the Parkway and other contemporaneous efforts, Gandy (at 122) comments that "Nature became simultaneously more distant (framed by the window of a moving car), more accessible (through greater public contact with remote areas), and at the same time more individualized as an aesthetic experience." In other words, the automobile as a technology system created a new, and unique, experience of "nature" -- not alone, of course, for the automobile, the Parkway, and other infrastructure were in turn representative of a certain moment in history and culture.
But consider "nature" through the window of the automobile -- and then as it appears through the window of the television, still more distant, yet, thanks to the power of "nature" photography, even closer, more emotionally evocative, and more accessible. Nothing is more artificial and contrived, more designed and planned, than the "nature" program on TV -- and more culturally potent, for that matter. And, finally, there is "nature" as it appears on the Net in at least three guises. The first is virtual reality: as bandwidth and processing power grow, "nature" will become largely a human creation, whether in video games or created experiential landscapes of the future. The second is in complex models interpreting massive data sets: a "nature" that because it is "scientific" will appear more real than the former, but will be just as constructed and ideological. And, of course, consumers will increasingly buy their "nature," from geode to cactus garden, not just from the museum or nature store at the mall, but over the Internet: "nature" as e-commerce.
This progression marks the increasing mediation of technological systems between whatever is "out there" and human perception and cognition; the evolution of a "nature" derived from human information structures rather than direct experience. It also marks the increasing commoditi-zation of "nature." The question of whether this evolution is desirable is an open one; what is amazing, however, is that it is largely unseen.
For many, including if not especially environmental professionals and activists, "nature" remains a foundational reality, its character as a constantly changing cultural construct not even recognized. Unfortunately, in the progression from perception, to analysis, to understanding, to wisdom, we have not yet really even begun. And thus the profound intellectual challenge still posed to us by the Bronx River Parkway of 1925.
-- Brad Allenby
Allenby is Environment, Health and Safety Vice President for AT&T, an adjunct professor at the University of Virginia’s Engineering School and Princeton Theological Seminary, and Batten Fellow at the University of Virginia’s Darden Business School. The views expressed herein are those of the author, and not any institution with which he is associated.
Many interesting threads lead from these seemingly simple examples. One could, for example, examine how the Parkway, and other roads like it, helped break down the physical boundaries of the city. One could contemplate "nature" as thus constructed from many angles: conservation of species, reconstruction of (highly idealized) landscapes, statements of power and class in a rapidly developing, immigrant-rich America. Thus, for example, Robert Moses designed low bridges over his parkway to Jones Beach on Long Island to prevent buses, and thus the lower classes, from accessing it -- although there was plenty of parking for the cars of the middle class. One could contemplate how each project explicitly redefined "nature" as a designed and built environment at the time, yet came to be seen by future generations as "natural" in a foundational sense.
But another aspect caught my eye. Referring to the Parkway and other contemporaneous efforts, Gandy (at 122) comments that "Nature became simultaneously more distant (framed by the window of a moving car), more accessible (through greater public contact with remote areas), and at the same time more individualized as an aesthetic experience." In other words, the automobile as a technology system created a new, and unique, experience of "nature" -- not alone, of course, for the automobile, the Parkway, and other infrastructure were in turn representative of a certain moment in history and culture.
But consider "nature" through the window of the automobile -- and then as it appears through the window of the television, still more distant, yet, thanks to the power of "nature" photography, even closer, more emotionally evocative, and more accessible. Nothing is more artificial and contrived, more designed and planned, than the "nature" program on TV -- and more culturally potent, for that matter. And, finally, there is "nature" as it appears on the Net in at least three guises. The first is virtual reality: as bandwidth and processing power grow, "nature" will become largely a human creation, whether in video games or created experiential landscapes of the future. The second is in complex models interpreting massive data sets: a "nature" that because it is "scientific" will appear more real than the former, but will be just as constructed and ideological. And, of course, consumers will increasingly buy their "nature," from geode to cactus garden, not just from the museum or nature store at the mall, but over the Internet: "nature" as e-commerce.
This progression marks the increasing mediation of technological systems between whatever is "out there" and human perception and cognition; the evolution of a "nature" derived from human information structures rather than direct experience. It also marks the increasing commoditi-zation of "nature." The question of whether this evolution is desirable is an open one; what is amazing, however, is that it is largely unseen.
For many, including if not especially environmental professionals and activists, "nature" remains a foundational reality, its character as a constantly changing cultural construct not even recognized. Unfortunately, in the progression from perception, to analysis, to understanding, to wisdom, we have not yet really even begun. And thus the profound intellectual challenge still posed to us by the Bronx River Parkway of 1925.
-- Brad Allenby
Allenby is Environment, Health and Safety Vice President for AT&T, an adjunct professor at the University of Virginia’s Engineering School and Princeton Theological Seminary, and Batten Fellow at the University of Virginia’s Darden Business School. The views expressed herein are those of the author, and not any institution with which he is associated.
Sponsored Links
In the just-published State of Green Business 2010 report, we take an extensive look at the data behind the move toward making mainstream businesses greener.
Click here to read all of our in-depth coverage of the State of Green Business, and to download the report.
Professional Services Directory
Find great professional service providers who specialize in green business. GreenBiz.com's Professional Services Directory lists great resources in sustainability strategies, energy efficiency, marketing, supply chain, recruiting and HR, and many more.
Advertisement
Featured Resources
This report from EcoAlign's EcoPinion series of surveys explores how the Energy Star...
The startup Aquacue offers a look at the innovations that landed it among the 10...
This eighth annual Clean Energy Trends report takes stock of the sector against the...
This book from Seventh Generation's Jeffrey Hollender and Bill Breem equips people with...
This slideshow from Cisco Systems outlines some of the steps the company has taken to...
This white paper from Environmental Defense Fund and fleet management company PHH Arval...
In 2010, we're bringing our acclaimed State of Green Business Forum to San Francisco and Chicago, digging in to the research in the annual State of Green Business report to discover recent trends in green business and hear from industry experts about what the future will hold. Read all our coverage of the events here.
Advertisement
Site Sponsors
A Corporate Finance Approach to Climate-Stabilizing Targets
Learn Autodesk’s method for setting corporate greenhouse gas targets that align with global climate stabilization goals—and how you can adopt it.
A monthly metric on responsibility, information, and purchasing in the green economy. The Green Confidence Index is the first ongoing consumer study of its kind. Learn More.
Recent News
- Is the Energy Star Brand Losing its Edge?
- United Biscuits Meets Water Goal 10 Years Early
- Sex Toy Company's Green Efforts Fail to Arouse
- Unilever Leads Food and Beverage Industry on Sustainability
- How Companies That Aggressively Pursue Sustainability Reap Rewards
- Organic Textile Certifications Grow 40 Percent
- Las Vegas Sands Raises the Stakes for Green Development
GreenerBuildings.com - OfficeMax Reusable Shipping Bins Deliver Less Waste
GreenerDesign.com - Anheuser-Busch InBev Wants to be World's Greenest Brewer
- Sainsbury's to Enhance Eco-Store Experience with Swarms of Bees
Recent Blogs
- The Problems with 'Natural' Products -- and How to Fix Them
- Embrace Sustainability or Put Your Business at Risk
- The Softer Side of Sustainability
- Lotus Leaf Demonstrates Business Case for Bio-Inspired Products
GreenerDesign.com - Fuel, Vitamins, Soap Help Solazyme Algae Stand out from Pond Scum
- Walmart's Emerging Role in Sustainability Consulting
- Fending Off the 'New Barbarians' with a Culture of Innovation
- Simple Tools for Effective Climate Reporting
ClimateBiz.com - Microsoft Puts Its Weight Behind IT's Energy-Saving Potential
- Walmart, Marks & Spencer, Nike: Harbingers of Change?

Browse
Engage
Research


