Featured Sponsor
What a Silent Spring Means for Business Risk
Published March 05, 2007
The current catastrophic loss of honeybee colonies around the world may mean immediate bad news for agriculture, but it also offers an important lesson for companies that are not looking at their dependence on ecosystem services when examining risk or growth opportunities, Noam Ross argues.
If your business's only supplier of a key service folded all of a sudden, what would you do?
That is what a lot of agricultural companies are asking themselves right now. As reported in the New York Times last week, honeybee colonies in 24 states have collapsed. Colony populations have crashed by 30-70 percent, causing bee prices to skyrocket at and sending a $14 billion agricultural sector scrambling for insects to pollinate their crops. Yet there are not many options out there. The U.S. agriculture has grown increasingly dependent on trucked-in bees as natural pollinator populations have declined from habitat fragmentation and pesticides since the mid-20th century.
This failure was almost entirely predictable. The Millennium Ecosystem Assessment warned in 2005 that the agricultural community was over-reliant on the domesticated honeybee as a pollination service provider, and that the bee was prone to disease and parasite problems.
If a business had such a clear warning about its supply chain, one would think it would work to diversify or at least do what they could to shore up their suppliers to ensure their continued viability. Yet as we're learning from the bee crisis, few companies examine the risks related to ecosystem services, like pollination, that they rely on. These risks may be large -- according to the Millennium Assessment, two-thirds of ecosystems worldwide are being degraded or used unsustainably, and degradation will likely accelerate over the next 50 years.
There are a few cases of companies taking a proactive approach to ecosystem management. ForestRe, a forest insurance company, recognized that forests around the Panama canal help regulate water supplies to the canal and prevent excessive erosion that could block it. It convinced a consortium of insurers, Asian automakers and Wal-Mart to pay for re-forestation around the Panama canal to mitigate the risks of a shut-down.
For the most part, though, companies are not looking at their dependence on ecosystem services when examining risk or growth opportunities. This is not entirely their own fault; while there is a vast and growing body of scientific knowledge on these services, there have been few business-friendly tools developed to help companies analyze this topic.
This is very different than the current state of business sophistication when it comes to climate change. These days, companies have a slew of case studies, reports, and tools to help them figure out how to deal with climate change issues. Pressure from shareholders and groups like the Carbon Disclosure Project has forced firms to assess and report on their carbon portfolio. Financial powerhouses like UBS and Lehman Brothers are issuing report after report on climate risk management. And an army of nonprofit and for-profit consultants is out there to hold hands through it all.
Assessment tools are going to have to play catch-up as businesses confront the global degradation of ecosystems. An important first step, though, is coming from a collaboration between The World Business Council for Sustainable Development, along with the World Resources Institute and the Meridian Institute.
"After the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment came out, the business community said 'Wow, this is amazing as well as disconcerting. But what do we do about it?'" says Craig Hanson, of the World Resources Institute. "At the end of the day a company needs to translate those findings into business strategy. That's what we were hearing from the business community. Hence the idea to create a set of tools."
Hanson is leading the development of a "Corporate Ecosystem Services Review", a methodology to assess business risk and new opportunities arising from the damaged state of ecosystems. The review will be designed to help companies figure out what ecosystem services they depend on and impact most, and then devise strategies to deal with the risks and opportunities represented.
"[The tool] is quite systematic, and there's value in that," says Hanson. "There are whole suites of services that we don't even think about, such as erosion control and climate regulation. All these services are taken for granted, yet many businesses depend on them." With key ecosystem services identified, businesses can mitigate the risk of their failure by partnering with local communities or other industries to protect the ecosystems they rely on, or lobbying governments for stronger ecosystem protection policies.
The Ecosystem Services Review is due out this Fall, and is currently being road-tested by companies in multiple industries and across four different continents. These include power provider BC Hydro, paper producer The Mondi Group, mining group Rio Tinto, and the agribusiness Syngenta.
Global ecosystem degradation may be as big a threat as climate change. We all stand to lose a lot if its risks are ignored, but those companies that figure out where the opportunities are could make a bundle.
Noam Ross is an analyst at GreenOrder, an LRN company. The strategy and management consulting firm has helped leading companies turn sustainability into business value since 2000.
If your business's only supplier of a key service folded all of a sudden, what would you do?
That is what a lot of agricultural companies are asking themselves right now. As reported in the New York Times last week, honeybee colonies in 24 states have collapsed. Colony populations have crashed by 30-70 percent, causing bee prices to skyrocket at and sending a $14 billion agricultural sector scrambling for insects to pollinate their crops. Yet there are not many options out there. The U.S. agriculture has grown increasingly dependent on trucked-in bees as natural pollinator populations have declined from habitat fragmentation and pesticides since the mid-20th century.
This failure was almost entirely predictable. The Millennium Ecosystem Assessment warned in 2005 that the agricultural community was over-reliant on the domesticated honeybee as a pollination service provider, and that the bee was prone to disease and parasite problems.
If a business had such a clear warning about its supply chain, one would think it would work to diversify or at least do what they could to shore up their suppliers to ensure their continued viability. Yet as we're learning from the bee crisis, few companies examine the risks related to ecosystem services, like pollination, that they rely on. These risks may be large -- according to the Millennium Assessment, two-thirds of ecosystems worldwide are being degraded or used unsustainably, and degradation will likely accelerate over the next 50 years.
There are a few cases of companies taking a proactive approach to ecosystem management. ForestRe, a forest insurance company, recognized that forests around the Panama canal help regulate water supplies to the canal and prevent excessive erosion that could block it. It convinced a consortium of insurers, Asian automakers and Wal-Mart to pay for re-forestation around the Panama canal to mitigate the risks of a shut-down.
For the most part, though, companies are not looking at their dependence on ecosystem services when examining risk or growth opportunities. This is not entirely their own fault; while there is a vast and growing body of scientific knowledge on these services, there have been few business-friendly tools developed to help companies analyze this topic.
This is very different than the current state of business sophistication when it comes to climate change. These days, companies have a slew of case studies, reports, and tools to help them figure out how to deal with climate change issues. Pressure from shareholders and groups like the Carbon Disclosure Project has forced firms to assess and report on their carbon portfolio. Financial powerhouses like UBS and Lehman Brothers are issuing report after report on climate risk management. And an army of nonprofit and for-profit consultants is out there to hold hands through it all.
Assessment tools are going to have to play catch-up as businesses confront the global degradation of ecosystems. An important first step, though, is coming from a collaboration between The World Business Council for Sustainable Development, along with the World Resources Institute and the Meridian Institute.
"After the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment came out, the business community said 'Wow, this is amazing as well as disconcerting. But what do we do about it?'" says Craig Hanson, of the World Resources Institute. "At the end of the day a company needs to translate those findings into business strategy. That's what we were hearing from the business community. Hence the idea to create a set of tools."
Hanson is leading the development of a "Corporate Ecosystem Services Review", a methodology to assess business risk and new opportunities arising from the damaged state of ecosystems. The review will be designed to help companies figure out what ecosystem services they depend on and impact most, and then devise strategies to deal with the risks and opportunities represented.
"[The tool] is quite systematic, and there's value in that," says Hanson. "There are whole suites of services that we don't even think about, such as erosion control and climate regulation. All these services are taken for granted, yet many businesses depend on them." With key ecosystem services identified, businesses can mitigate the risk of their failure by partnering with local communities or other industries to protect the ecosystems they rely on, or lobbying governments for stronger ecosystem protection policies.
The Ecosystem Services Review is due out this Fall, and is currently being road-tested by companies in multiple industries and across four different continents. These include power provider BC Hydro, paper producer The Mondi Group, mining group Rio Tinto, and the agribusiness Syngenta.
Global ecosystem degradation may be as big a threat as climate change. We all stand to lose a lot if its risks are ignored, but those companies that figure out where the opportunities are could make a bundle.
Noam Ross is an analyst at GreenOrder, an LRN company. The strategy and management consulting firm has helped leading companies turn sustainability into business value since 2000.
Professional Services Directory
Find great professional service providers who specialize in green business. GreenBiz.com's Professional Services Directory lists great resources in sustainability strategies, energy efficiency, marketing, supply chain, recruiting and HR, and many more.
Advertisement
Featured Resources
This concise and fact-filled guide, the latest book by Jerry Yudelson, provides a roadmap...
This study finds that a robust climate bill could boost the U.S. economy by about $111...
This study, conducted by the U.S. Green Building Council and Booz Allen Hamilton,...
This report is seventh in an annual series looking at impacts in the green buildings...
This second annual report, by Rob Watson and the GreenBiz.com editorial team, explores...
Citizen Engineer is a fusion of ideas, information, advice, and opinions to provide you...
GreenBiz.com Career Center
Find the green job that's right for you. GreenBiz.com's green job and career center has jobs in energy efficiency, protecting ecosystems, research and development, green building, administrative, and more. Employers can post jobs and internships for free.
Site Sponsors
Advertisement
Get the latest insights from IBM on best practices in sustainable enterprises, and a framework for crafting energy and environmental policies. Find out more here.
Walmart Sustainability Index

Get the story behind the Walmart Sustainability Index and what it means to your business. Read news stories and insights from Joel Makower, Marc Gunther, and the GreenBiz editors.
A monthly metric on responsibility, information, and purchasing in the green economy. The Green Confidence Index is the first ongoing consumer study of its kind. Learn More.
Sponsored Links
Recent News
- Kraft Trims Millions of Shipping Miles Through Smarter Logistics
- Wells Fargo Expands Green Financing with Cleantech Practice
- New, Green 'Safe Spoon' Goes Where Normal Utensils Can't
GreenerDesign.com - In a Rare NGO Merger, GreenBlue and Metafore Join Strengths
- US Uses Less Water Than It Did a Generation Ago As Global Concern Grows Over Scarcity
- SocialCycling Program Launched To Reuse Non-Recyclable Products, Materials
GreenerDesign.com - Survey to Explore Keys to Winning Employee Engagement Programs
- AU Optronics Helps Create a Frisbee-Shaped Solar Roof at Taipei Playground
GreenerBuildings.com - Post Office's First Sustainability Report Charts Agency's Green Path
- 50 Companies Add U.K.-Specific Recycling Label to Packaging
GreenerDesign.com
Recent Blogs
- Climate Counts and the Green Race to the Top
- How Silver Can Bring a New Element to Green Chemistry
GreenerDesign.com - What Does It Mean When Procurement Goes Green?
- Real Climate Leadership and the Rules of Policy Engagement
ClimateBiz.com - RSC Equipment Rental Rolls Out Emissions Tracking Service
GreenerBuildings.com - Rolling Towards Greener Tires
- How a Soft Energy Path Could Put China on the Right Track to Sustainable Growth
- The Language of Sustainability: Why Words Matter
- When Behavioral Economics Meets Climate Change, Guess What's Coming for Dinner?
ClimateBiz.com - How Energy Modeling Can Create 'Model Prisoners' & Closing Thoughts on Greenbuild 2009
GreenerBuildings.com

Browse
Engage
Research

