Earth Hour, which started in Australia in 2007, is a rapidly growing worldwide phenomenon urging people around the world to turn off their lights for one hour to recognize the impact that humans have on the environment. In the words of the WWF, the event's founders, it is "a global call to action for every individual, every business, and every community. A call to stand up and take control over the future of our planet." For this year's celebration, the organizers are expecting 1 billion people to participate.
One group that will steadfastly not be participating is the Competitive Enterprise Institute, which yesterday announced its own, competitive (of course) celebration: the mind-blowingly strange "Human Achievement Hour."
The CEI, of course, is the free-market advocacy group and think tank that has long espoused market-based, non-solution solutions to environmental crises. Recent CEI efforts include a "Celebrate Coal!" rally last month and a study that aimed to "debunked myths" about bottled water.
But Human Achievement Hour is on an entirely new level of strangeness. As near as I can tell, the "holiday" involves going about your normal day to day (or night-to-night, or hour-to-hour) business. In the words of the press release:
"We are so proud that millions of people plan to show their appreciation for human achievement by doing things like eating diner [sic], watching television, going to the movies, and brushing their teeth," says Human Achievement Hour Founder and CEI Policy Analyst Michelle Minton. "Never before has a new holiday caught on so quickly."In fact, this press release is so bizarre, and the wink-wink, nudge-nudge ridiculousness of the idea is buried only so shallowly under the surface, that it bears significant excerpting:
The new one-hour holiday, unknown prior to this press release, has already received overwhelming support from many of Washington, D.C.'s leading institutions. The Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority, for example, tells CEI that it does not plan to shut down all of the city's bus and rail lines for the "Earth Hour." The Kennedy Center, likewise, has scheduled a performance of the long-running play Sheer Madness, a jazz concert, and a dance performance to coincide with the Human Achievement Hour. Washington, D.C.'s Target store, furthermore, will remain open until 10:00pm on the evening of the 28th. The Smithsonian Institution also plans a film showing that will extend into Human Achievement Hour.What's notably missing from these paragraphs is an asterisk, linking to the bottom of the press release, which says: "It goes without saying that, except for CEI itself, the institutions listed above have not actually endorsed 'Human Achievement Hour.'"
Other organizations around the world and the nation have planned events in support of the new holiday. For example, The United State Marine Corps will continue its combat and humanitarian operations around the world during Human Achievement Hour. The New York Times confirms that it intends to put out a paper on March 29th, 2009 (preparation and printing for that issue will take place during Human Achievement Hour). At least 30,000 movies will also be screened in celebration of Human Achievement Hour. Hospital emergency and operating rooms, likewise, will remain open in Washington and in the rest of the country. Nearly all of the nation's Wal-Mart locations will also be open during Human Achievement Hour.
I tell you: this is just too befuddling a "news" announcement to have waiting for me on a Friday morning. I don't know if the Earth Hour organizers are including in their billion-participant expectations all the world's people who don't have electricity in their homes (and thus are de facto "celebrating" Earth Hour every night), but the CEI is rather explicitly shepherding everyone in the world who isn't turning out lights into their "Human Achievement Hour" campaign.
So I guess that's what it comes down to: are you going to turn out your lights for an hour, or are you going to side with the CEI? Thanks to the CEI, I now know which side I'm on...














Thanks
Thanks for drawing attention to Human achievemnt hour. I myself was too busy celebrating Edison Hour to be able to participate. Wait a minute...
Thank goodness for CEI
Honestly, some alternate energy solutions are necessary, whether or not global warming exists; we should always be looking for more efficient energy. However, those who believe we should stop using energy altogether are anti-humanistic in the worst way.
Sure, don't leave the lights on when you leave the room. That goes along with not, say, pouring fresh, unopened containers of food into the sea. But eating the food (or using the electricity) remains necessary for a high standard of living. The idea behind Earth Hour is severely flawed. Rather than ceasing to use energy altogether, people should promote research into more efficient/sustainable forms of energy.
Of course
Of course you don't understand the point of "human achievement hour". You're a greenie. I've not met one yet that had a significant contribution to make to society.
Gimme Money
“As near as I can tell, the "holiday" involves going about your normal day to day (or night-to-night, or hour-to-hour) business.”
That is the point they wish to make! They wish to celebrate the achievements that bratty westerners like you take for granted: readily available entertainment, electricity, water and fresh food while simultaneously highlighting that you wish to destroy those accomplishments. They wish to show that you are not pro-earth, but anti-civilization.
Well, you guys can go and
Well, you guys can go and turn off you lights and sit in the dark. Good for you.
Make sure you keep blogging away on those humming PCs and laptops ;)
HAH FTW!
I say we have HAH 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and 365 days a year!
Oh wait, we already do.
One of the saddest things to
One of the saddest things to behold is people upon whom satire and sarcasm are completely wasted...
Weary_G
God bless CEI. Nothing could
God bless CEI. Nothing could make me want to spend an hour turning on every appliance in my kitchen more than you absurd greens and your egotistical "plans" for the 4.5 billion year old earth. Never heard of earth hour before, but everyone in my neighborhood will know i'm celebrating it. cheers...
Are you REALLY that dim? (No
Are you REALLY that dim? (No pun intended.) The whole point of HAH is that most people aren't even aware of the ridiculous Earth Hour - and will go on with their daily lives in the face of it. The CEI doesn't have to asterisk anything in its release for people of average intelligence to get what they're saying.
Dum article...
Is this a joke and what does it help...
Sarcasm is the lowest form of humor and the CEI is a self-promoting group of anti-action folks. When will we move past the sense of comedic rhetoric and start taking our own survival seriously...
If even 1000 people wake-up that their lights relate to energy use and that they have a role to play in the world's climate awareness... then promote it!
It is always so much easier to destroy then to build and yet again you have proven that sad human point...nice work!
Not all all true Matthew
There is not a dichotomy of choosing fighting climate change or being in favor of human achievement with CEI's event as you put it. The idea that I am getting from this and the explanation on the wiki site is that this is to celebrate human invention and achievement. Running a marathon is human achievement, and doesn't use any electricity at all. The only negative thing about it is the fact that one would have to exhale carbon dioxide to stay alive, which may promote climate change in some of your readers minds. But the point is all human achievements do not use electricity or "pollute" so there is no dichotomy of being for it or against it. If there is a dichotomy it is one of being responsible care takers of our environment versus using scare tactics to promote a man made global warming scare that has seen evidence of the contrary for the last 7 years. No increase in temps, growth of the polar ice caps, no more drowning fake robotic polar bears or film from a movie of sheets of ice falling into the oceans.
CEI
started with exxon funds, part of the coal is clean bunch. shows us how crazy they are....
http://cei.org/news-release/2009/03/19/cei-announces-%E2%80%9Chuman-achi...
From CEI:
Myron Ebell
Director of Energy and Global Warming Policy
Myron Ebell is director of energy and global warming policy at CEI. He also chairs the Cooler Heads Coalition, which comprises over two dozen non-profit groups in this country and abroad that question global warming alarmism and oppose energy rationing policies.
I'm going to :
turn EVERY single light on, the pc, the tv, the stereo, guitar amps, everything I have that uses electricity!! I think I'll call it "Kiss my A$$, AL GORE hour"
Not exactly the point
Obviously there are no shortage of positive impacts from human civilization -- and obviously at GreenBiz.com we're hoping for an increase in those -- but that's not the point of the CEI's event.
My sense from receiving their emails and reading through their site in the past is that, like with everything else they promote, it's better for you and I as individuals to do nothing and let the market take care of these issues.
So instead of saying "it's good that you all are concerned about the climate, take your hour of darkness and have fun," CEI is instead setting up a dichotomy where you are either in favor of fighting climate change or you're in favor of "human achievement" as a synonym for industry as usual.
I'm confused
Human achievements are bad things? What about the achievements that have had positive impacts on the earth?