A Building Group Goes After Washington State's Energy Code

Published January 20, 2011

Last week, we looked at Air Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute (ACHRI) v. City of Albuquerque, a case in which a federal court struck down portions of the Albuquerque Energy Conservation Code based on the doctrine of federal preemption.

In a construction code context, federal preemption often means that products and appliances are regulated at the federal level but states regulate building codes.

The decision in the Albuquerque case was not all that surprising as the code clearly went beyond federal efficiency standards for heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) products.

But a more recent case involving similar claims of federal preemption is not so clear.

On May 25, 2010, the Building Industry Association of Washington (BIAW) and nine HVAC manufacturers and installers, filed a lawsuit in federal court against the Washington State Building Code Council. The lawsuit alleges that one portion of a new Washington State Energy Code related to single-family residential energy efficiency is preempted by federal law. The plaintiffs have asked for an injunction against the code.

Changes to the state code were passed on November 20, 2009, and the new code went into effect July 1, 2010. Plaintiffs are particularly concerned with residential energy efficiency requirements under Chapter 9. I would suggest you download a copy of the complaint (PDF) and take a look at the chapter, which is attached as an exhibit starting on page 16. Here is a sample of the table from Chapter 9:

Green Jobs Outpace Overall California Job Market Recovery The most recent job growth data for California shows which regions are leading and lagging in green job growth....	PepsiCo Could Be 'Fossil Fuel Free' by 2023 The company's 'Path to Zero' program delivers significant cuts in its water and power consumption; also included in the project are shifts to renewable, recyclable or biodegradable packaging....
FedEx Express Global HQ, Vegas Facility Earn LEED-Gold Ratings With two of its more high-profile facilities recognized as green buildings, FedEx Express is making LEED certification a requirement for all new construction. The move by FedEx's cargo airline is the latest sustainability measure to emerge under the rubric of the corporation's EarthSmart program....	BNY Mellon's Energy Star Data Center Saves Millions in Energy Costs In the past five years, the facility outside Pittsburgh has saved 80 million kilowatts of energy use, trimming $7.5 million from the bank's energy bills, and is in the process of getting LEED certification as well....
BPA Bans, Chemical Reform Laws in the Works in 30 States New bills in 30 states will try to ban bisphenol A and reform the federal government's chemical policies this year....	Walmart Donates $2M for Food Bank Energy Efficiency Walmart's charity arm is donating $2 million to more than a dozen food banks in the U.S. to fund energy-efficiency programs....
Can Geoengineering Save Australia? Australia's "worst flood disaster in living memory" threatens to swamp Brisbane, the country's third-biggest city, while the southern part of the continent suffers through an unprecedented decade-long drought. A longtime climate scientist things geoengineering could ease some of the country's climate change-related pain....	What Every Business Leader Needs to Know About Sustainability It's essential for a company's senior executives and board members to have a strong understanding of sustainability issues, and a new book from global management consultancy Arthur D. Little is aimed at providing the foundation for that learning....

Blogs

A Building Group Goes After Washington State's Energy Code

GreenBiz Events