China drives toward sustainable freight policies
In China, trucks dominate the freight transport market and their use is increasing at a fast rate — in 2014, this transportation method was used to move more than 33 billion tonnes of freight in the country, more than 75 percent of the total and 22 times higher than in 1980.
As a result, freight trucks are the fastest-growing source of emissions from the transport sector. While they account for only 15 percent of the total vehicles in China (excluding motorcycles), they contributed more than 50 percent of vehicle carbon dioxide (CO2), 35 percent of carbon monoxide, 41 percent of hydrocarbons, 68 percent of nitrogen oxides and 79 percent of particulate matter emissions in 2014 (PDF).
Road freight vehicles, especially heavy-duty trucks, are recognized as the most polluted mode of transport, contributing significantly to poor air quality. The World Health Organization has found a strong link between air pollution exposure and public health. Air pollution also negatively impacts the country's economy. In China, the total welfare loss due to outdoor air pollution was an equivalent of 9.9 percent (PDF) of GPD.
Little wonder that transport experts are trying to find solutions to achieve green, smart and inclusive freight transport in China.
A fragmented and unorganized market
The challenge is a large one. Road freight has the dubious honor of being the most unorganized market in China’s transport sector. According to China’s Ministry of Transport, the road freight market is challenged by "3 lows and 1 high": low concentration; low technology level; low efficiency; and high fuel consumption. Here's more color on what those designations mean:
- Low concentration — Current trucking companies in China are characterized as "small, fragmented and weak." More than 90 percent of the freight market is dominated by a large number of small companies with fewer than 10 trucks; most of these companies are "owner-driver" firms, and there were more than 6 million of them in 2015. The market is highly competitive, labor-intensive and not very profitable.
- Low technology level — China’s road freight sector is characterized by poor truck and facilities conditions, illegal truck retrofitting and a lack of standards, logistics information systems and intelligent transport systems.
- Low efficiency — The average operational efficiency of road freight systems in China is lower than 60 percent, which is 33 percent lower than developed countries. In addition, road tolls are a major cost for trucking companies. Truckers have to choose less efficient routes in order to avoid excess road tolls. Additionally, excessive road tolls also contribute to overloading and oversized trucks.
- High fuel consumption — China’s truck fleet is not fuel-efficient; its fuel consumption is 25 percent, 20 percent and 10 percent higher than Europe, Japan and the United States respectively. In addition, most trucks cannot meet the required emissions standards.
Solutions for achieving smart road freight
Due to the inherent challenges of the freight system in China, green freight was a major topic of discussion during the World Metropolitan Transport Development Forum (WMTD). In October, more than 500 participants gathered in Beijing to discuss challenges and solutions for sustainable transport development. WRI China, Beijing Municipal Commission of Transport (BMCT) and Beijing Transport Institute (BTI) co-organized the forum, striving to encourage city leaders and transport professionals to address challenges in urban mobility.
During the forum, experts from around the world discussed methods to improve freight transport. WRI’s China team summarized the key takeaways and potential sustainable solutions:
- Multimodal freight transport and transshipment methods — China should encourage more multimodal freight transportation, especially to improve the intermodal transshipment (moving cargo from one mode of transport to another) in logistics hubs to enhance the connectivity of rail, waterway/port, road and air systems. International experience shows that efficient multimodal operation can save around 40 percent of emissions.
- Internet plus logistics — The traditional places for transaction and information exchange cannot meet the requirement of today’s logistics market. More and more logistics companies are applying the "Internet Plus Logistics" concept and "Uber-like" apps, such as Truck Alliance, to do route planning and cross-docking. To enhance logistics efficiency, Big Data and the new information technologies soon will replace the traditional information platforms. Experience shows that Internet technology can help reduce 30 percent to 50 percent of empty miles (distance traveled by trucks without loading any cargo) in China.
- Drop-and-hook (tractor-trailer) approaches — Drop-and-hook is a method to organize transport and trailer pool management to reduce empty miles and dwelling time (the waiting time for trucks to load and unload), and eventually optimize performance. "Drop" refers to delivering a trailer and dropping at the customer site (or a distribution center), and "hook" refers to immediately hooking up a loaded trailer and moving it to the destination. Evidence from Guangzhou trucking companies at the WMTD forum shows that drop-and-hook can save about 34 percent of logistics costs.
- New-energy trucks and clean technologies — Most practitioners encourage new-energy vehicles and clean technologies (PDF). Electric trucks, which have reduced noise and zero tank-to-wheel emissions are especially suitable for urban deliveries with frequent stop-and-go conditions. Experience from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency SmartWay Program shows that trucks can reduce 5 percent to 85 percent of their fuel emissions by using a combination of the verified clean technologies.
- Low-emission zones and standards — China also needs to introduce low-emission zones (LEZ) and enhance vehicle emission standards nationwide. According to WRI’s recent study, LEZs can reduce particulate matter and nitrogen oxides by 25 percent and 10 percent, respectively. Furthermore, introducing LEZs in 20 major Chinese cities can also reduce more than 100 million tonnes of carbon dioxide by 2030.
Creating a cohesive, green logistics industry
A smart, green and inclusive freight market depends on the eco-efficiency of the logistics chain as a whole. Fortunately, China’s logistics stakeholders already have started to work together on establishing a green logistics industry.
China Road Transport Association, the biggest transport association in China, has been conducting a China Green Freight Initiative in recent years, establishing a strong stakeholder network to promote green freight.
Elsewhere, China’s Ministry of Transport also identified green freight as a top priority in its 13th Five-Year Strategy (PDF) on environmental protection for transport. The government intends for freight carbon dioxide emissions to decrease by 7 percent to 8 percent by 2020. Fleets also will be required to meet even more air pollutant reductions in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei, Yangtze River Delta and Pearl River Delta regions.
All of these initiatives point to a more sustainable transport sector and a greener logistics market.