Apple, Sony Ericsson Earn Kudos for Removing Toxics from Electronics

Apple, Sony Ericsson Earn Kudos for Removing Toxics from Electronics

A report released today by ChemSec and Clean Production Action highlights the innovations driven by electronics manufacturers that have removed toxics like bromine and chlorine from high-tech gadgets.

The report, "Greening Consumer Electronics: moving away from bromine and chlorine," offers case studies of seven electronics companies that have overhauled their product designs through a combination of transparency around product materials and working with suppliers to develop safer alternatives to brominated and chlorinated chemicals.

“These seven companies demonstrate that there are less toxic and still cost effective alternatives to substances of high concern that do not compromise performance or reliability,” CPA Project Director Alexandra McPherson said in a statement. “They are well positioned to gain competitive advantage in a marketplace and regulatory environment increasingly sensitive to the use of toxic chemicals in consumer products.”

At least some of the impetus for the design successes highlighted in this report come as a result of the Restrictrion on Hazardous Substances (RoHS) law, enacted in 2006 in the European Union; since then similar laws have been adopted in South Korea, Turkey, China and Japan. That law restricts the use of six toxic materials, including two brominated chemicals.
In the wake of RoHS restrictions, as well as pressure from customers and NGOs, Apple and Sony Ericsson in particular have reformulated product lines to restrict or eliminate entirely the use of bromine and chlorine in products. Apple now has a number of polyvinyl chloride-free (PVC) and brominated flame retardant-free (BFR) product lines, including iPhones, iPods and a number of the company's computers.

The plaudits in today's report top off a string of recent environmental achievements from Apple; last week the company opened the doors on the emissions impacts of its product line, and yesterday the company withdrew from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce over the Chamber's anti-climate legislation actions.

Sony Ericsson has not only removed these substances from their products -- all are 99.9 percent BFR free and will be 100 percent PVC free by the end of 2009 -- but the company is also developing full chemical inventories for all of their product lines as well.

Full material disclosure was one of the keys to success for another of the companies profiled in the report. Seagate, the world's largest manufacturer of disk drives, implemented a product stewardship policy in 2005 that has led to releasing a full chemical inventory of all of its products, as well as achieving PVC- and BFR-free formulations of 50 percent of the products it ships.

In order to spread these innovations and encourage other manufacturers to adopt these principles, the report's authors urge global adoption of regulatory guidelines like RoHS, as well as supply chain specifications that allow manufacturers to verify that these materials are removed from suppliers' products and broader adoption of green procurement criteria like the EPEAT standard for green computing products.

The full report, Greening Consumer Electronics: moving away from bromine and chlorine," is available for download from, and includes more case studies and detailed descriptions of how these companies have succeeded, and how other firms can make similar progress. More details are available online at and